|

LEGAL PRIVATISATION ISSUES IN INDIA
Rajiv K. Luthra and P. Pakhiddey,
Luthra & Luthra Law Offices I
The year 1991 marked the beginning of
India’s liberalisation and economic reforms
programme as the country decided to initiate
steps towards globalisation of its economy.
Towards this end, new policies were
promulgated, which substantially modified
the restrictions placed on foreign
investment, industrial licensing etc. and
revamped its foreign investment policy by
abolishing import licensing and removing
certain constraints imposed by the Foreign
Exchange Regulation Act, 1973, allowing
acquisition of immovable property by foreign
nationals, employment of foreigners and
remittance of income earned by them.
Steps have been taken to simplify tax
administration and moderate the tax rates
and broad base taxation, abolition of wealth
tax on financial assets, and reduction in
tax rates on foreign companies to 48%.
India has become a member of Multilateral
Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA). As a
consequence, all investments approved by the
Government are insured against expropriation
/ nationalisation by MIGA.
DISINVESTMENT
At the time of Independence in August, 1947,
it was felt that political independence
without economic self reliance would be
detrimental to the country’s sovereignty and
autonomy. Hence, the public sector was
introduced with a view to :
-
build infrastructure to promote rapid
economic growth and industrialisation ;
-
create employment opportunities and promote
balanced regional development ;
-
create a self reliant economy by developing
local industries ; and
-
prevent/reduce concentration of private
economic power.
The public sector policy was largely guided
by the Industrial Policy Resolution of 1956
which gave the public sector a strategic
role in the economy. Massive investments
have been made over the past four decades in
the public sector. However, after the
initial exuberance of the public sector had
died down, some problems were observed in
terms of low productivity, poor project
management skills, overmanning, lack of
modern technology, inadequate attention to
R&D and low priority to human resource
development. These and other economic
compulsions led to the adoption of a new
approach towards the public sector.
In 1991 the Government issued a Statement on
Industrial Policy which called for a review
of the portfolio of public sector
investments, the selective opening of the
public sector, to the private sector, the
referral of sick public enterprises to the
Board of Industrial and Financial
Reconstruction, the offering a part of the
Government share holding in the public
sector to mutual funds, financial
institutions, general public and workers,
and making the boards of public sector
companies more professional and performance
oriented.
The Disinvestment Commission was constituted
in August, 1996 and 40 PSUs were referred to
the Commission for advice. Later, 10 more
PSUs were referred to the Commission.
As per the recommendations of the
Disinvestment Commission, the strategy on
disinvestment revolves around four long term
objectives :
-
strengthen PSUs where appropriate in order
to facilitate disinvestment ;
-
protect employee interests ;
-
broad base ownership ; and
-
augment receipts for Government.
The Commission has recommended that a
Disinvestment Fund (DF), administered by the
Ministry of Finance, be set up and the
proceeds of the disinvestment be placed
separately in such Fund.
To ensure implementation of the
recommendations of the Commission, it has
recommended that a Standing Empowered Group
(SEG) be formed comprising the Cabinet
Secretary, Secretaries of the Ministry of
Finance, Department of Public Enterprises,
Administrative Ministry of the PSU, along
with the CEO of the PSU concerned.
The Government has agreed with the view of
the Disinvestment Commission that the
essence of a long-term disinvestment
strategy should be not only to enhance
budgetary receipts, but also minimise
budgetary support towards unprofitable units
while ensuring their long-term viability and
sustainable levels of employment.
A total amount of Rs. 12,455 crores has
already been disinvested to the public
sector financial institutions, mutual funds
and general public.
SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS
Powergrid Corporation of India Limited (Powergrid).
(Share capital : US $ 787 m). Powergrid was
set up in 1989 to construct extra high
voltage AC and high power direct current
transmission lines, sub-stations, road
dispatch centres and communication
facilities to transmit power from central
generating agency and surplus if any from
State Electricity Boards, to load centres
within and across the geographical regions,
reliably and economically. Its share capital
is Rs. 2992.24/- crore.
The Commission is of the view that until the
entire power sector is reformed, Powergrid
may not be able to attract the right kind of
response from institutional or other
investors to consider disinvestment.
Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited (ONGC)
(Share capital : US $ 375.3 m). The
principal activity of ONGC is the
exploration and production of crude oil and
natural gas. Its share capital is Rs. 1426
crores. The Government has disinvested 2% of
its share to mutual funds, financial
institutions and 2% to its employees. ONGC
is undertaking a detailed review of its
operations for the purpose of restructuring
and reorganisation. The Commission has
recommended that disinvestment in ONGC be
considered after the organisational changes
are in position and the new pricing policy
is known.
Gas Authority of India Limited (GAIL)
(Share capital : US $ 222.4 m). GAIL has
an approximate 13% share in overall LPG
production in the country and about 32%
share in gas-based LPG production. Its
paid-up share capital is Rs. 845.3 crores.
Disinvestment to the extent of 25% of the
total equity capital is recommended for
distribution between the domestic and
international market, depending upon the
market conditions. The price, exact timing
and selection of global coordinators for the
GDR issue will be done by SEG.
Hindustan Copper Limited (HCL) (Equity :
US $ 89 m). HCL was set up in 1967 to
manufacture copper products. Its equity is
Rs. 338.20 crores. In 1995, the Government
of India disinvested about 1% of the total
equity in favour of financial institutions.
The Commission has recommended two options
for disinvestment :
HCL may implement its expansion projects,
after which the Government may select a
strategic partner for the company through an
open and competitive bidding process
offering 51% equity of the company. The
Government may also disinvest 23% of the
equity through an offer of shares in the
domestic market to financial institutions,
small investors and employees; or
To select a strategic partner straight away
and offer 51% equity. After the completion
of its expansion project, the Government may
disinvest further 23% of the equity in the
domestic market to institutions, small
investors and employees.
Bharat Aluminium Company Limited (BALCO)
(Share capital : US $ 128.4 m). BALCO
has a market share of around 17% (including
exports) in the aluminum industry. Its
paid-up share capital is Rs. 488 crores. The
Commission has recommended that the
Government may immediately disinvest its
holding in the company by offering 40% of
the equity to a strategic partner, either
domestic or foreign, through a transparent
and competitive bidding process.
India Tourism Development Corporation (ITDC)
(Share capital : US $ 17.8 m). ITDC
operates 26 hotels, 30 duty/tax free shops
and provides travel and tourist services. It
has an equity share capital of Rs. 67.5
crores with a tangible net worth of Rs. 1480
crores (US $ 389 m). The Commission has
recommended that disinvestment can go up to
74% or more. In respect of hotels located in
prime locations, they may be handed over to
established hotel chains through a
competitive bidding process to run on long
term structured contract on
lease-cum-management basis. Other hotels are
to be demerged into separate corporate
identities, whose shares will be issued to
Government and other shareholders in
exchange for ITDC shares.
Rail India Technical and Economic
Services Limited (RITES) (Equity capital :
US $ 0.3 m). RITES was incorporated in 1974
with the object of rendering consultancy
services primarily in all areas of rail
transportation, technology and management,
both in India and abroad. Its equity capital
is Rs. 1 crore. The Commission has
recommended that no disinvestment be made in
RITES as it is not likely to get a
favourable response from small investors and
the uncertainty surrounding certain dues
would preclude any disinvestment effort till
such issues are satisfactorily resolved.
Pawan Hans Helicopters Limited (PHL)
(Equity capital : US $ 30 m). PHL was
incorporated in 1985 for providing
helicopter services primarily to meet the
requirements of ONGC. Its equity capital is
Rs. 113.8 crores. The Commission recommended
that the Government should first offer its
share holding to ONGC so that PHL could
become its subsidiary. In the event that
ONGC is not interested, the Government
should sell its entire holding of 78.5% to
an investor.
Shipping Corporation of India (SCI)
(Equity : US $ 74.3 m). SCI was
incorporated in 1961. It owns 122 vessels
aggregating 5.44 million dwt and operates in
practically all areas of the shipping
industry. It also operates cargo and
passenger vessels owned by other Government
agencies. It has an equity of Rs. 282.3
crores. The Government has disinvested
19.88% of the equity to Unit Trust of India,
General Insurance Corporation, Life
Insurance Corporation and foreign
institutional investors. The Commission has
recommend that the Government should
disinvest in SCI in favour of the oil
refinery companies. Thirty per cent of the
equity of SCI may be offered to Indian Oil
Corporation, Hindustan Petroleum Corporation
Limited, Bharat Petroleum Corporation
Limited, Cochin Refinery Limited and Madras
Refinery Limited in proportion to their net
profits. In addition, 10% could be offered
to the private sector and joint sector
refineries. In the event this offer is not
accepted by the private sector refineries it
may be offered to the public sector
refineries in the manner already indicated.
Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (MTNL)
(Equity base : US $ 157.9 m). MTNL
provides basic telecom services in two
metropolitan cities- Delhi and Mumbai. It
has an equity base of Rs. 600 crores. The
Government has disinvested 34.27% of its
holding mainly in favour of financial
institutions, mutual funds and nationalised
banks. In November, 1997, GDR of equity
shares amounting to $ 358.74 m was issued in
the international market.
It is intended that the nine major PSUs (Navratnas)-
Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited, Bharat
Petroleum Corporation Limited, Hindustan
Petroleum Corporation Limited, Indian Oil
Corporation Limited, Indian Petrochemicals
Corporation Limited, National Thermal Power
Corporation Limited, Oil and Natural Gas
Corporation Limited, Steel Authority of
India Limited and Videsh Sanchar Nigam
Limited should become global giants and the
Cabinet has approved various measures to
give greater autonomy to these PSUs and
improve their operating environment.
|
Table I:
Summary of Recommendations on Individual
PSUs
|
|
Bharat Aluminium Co. |
Strategic sale of 40%
equity |
|
Bongaigon Refineries |
Strategic sale of 50%
share |
|
Container Corporation
of India |
Disinvestment upto
49% |
|
Gas Authority of
India Ltd. |
Disinvestment of 25%
of total equity |
|
HTL Ltd. |
Strategic sale |
|
Indian Telephone
Industries Ltd. |
Strategic sale |
|
India Tourism
Development Corporation |
Strategic sale of
specific hotels |
|
Kudremukh Iron Ore
Co. Ltd. |
Strategic sale up to
74% |
|
Madras Fertilisers
Ltd. |
Strategic sale |
|
Mahanagar Telephone
Nigam Ltd. |
Disinvestment up to
49 % |
|
Manganese Ore (India)
Ltd. |
Disinvestment up to
49% after restructuring |
|
Modern Food
Industries (India) Ltd. |
100% equity through
strategic sale |
|
Oil & Natural Gas
Corporation |
No Disinvestment at
present |
|
Oil India Ltd. |
No Disinvestment at
present |
|
Rail India
Technical and Economic Service Ltd.
|
No Disinvestment at
present |
FORMS OF FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
As part of the economic reforms programme,
policies and procedures governing foreign
investment and technology transfers have
been significantly simplified and
streamlined. Today, private sector
participation including foreign investment
is welcome in practically all sectors of the
economy, except those of strategic
importance such as railways, atomic energy,
defence etc.
Under the new Policy, all foreign
investments and returns on them are fully
repatriable, except where the condition of
dividend balancing is applicable. This
condition of dividend balancing has been
restricted to 22 industries in the consumer
goods sector.
The Reserve Bank of India accords automatic
approvals to all proposals for foreign
investment upto 51% of the equity of the
Indian company in high priority industries.
In certain sectors this limit for automatic
approvals has been raised to 74%.Foreign
equity upto 100% is allowed in certain
sectors on an individual case basis.
POLICY AND GUIDELINES ON PRIVATE
INVESTMENT IN VARIOUS SECTORS
Power. The private sector can set up
thermal, hydel, wind or solar energy based
projects without any limitation to their
size. Private sector companies may operate
either as licensees distributing power in a
licensed area from their own generation or
from purchased power, or as generating
companies generating power for supply to the
grid. Foreign investment in the power sector
is actively encouraged and can take place
either in the form of a joint venture with
an Indian partner or as a fully-owned
operation with 100% foreign equity.
Various State Electricity Boards are
planning to restructure their operations,
with the state of Orissa leading the way.
The Orissa State Electricity Board has been
divided into two: Grid Corporation and
Orissa Hydro Power Corporation. A regulatory
commission has also been set up. The Grid
Corporation of Orissa (Gridco) has invited
bids from private parties interested in
forming 51:49 joint ventures with Gridco to
manage the distribution of power in Orissa.
Haryana and Rajasthan are two other states
who are seeking Joint Ventures with the
private sector in distribution of power.
Foreign companies have submitted 35
proposals, worth US $ 23 bn for a capacity
addition of 22,432 MW.
Telecommunications. The Government
has announced a comprehensive policy for
attracting private, including foreign
investment in Value Added and Basic
Services. These are Electronic mail, voice
mail, data services, audio text services and
video text services. For paging and cellular
mobile telephones, a policy of selection
through a system of tendering is followed.
An autonomous body, the Telecom Regulatory
Authority of India (TRAI) has been set up to
set standards, regulate prices, ensure
technical compatibility among different
service providers, fix access charges,
protect consumer interest and resolve
disputes between service providers.
Licences have been issued to 14 companies
for paging services in 27 cities, for
e-mail, voice mail and cellular services.
Cellular and paging services by private
operators have commenced in most parts of
the country. For providing basic telephone
services, 18 bidders have submitted 80 bids
covering all telecom circles except Jammu &
Kashmir.
Hydrocarbons. Foreign companies can
invest upto 100% of the equity in any
venture in the Petroleum Sector subject to
approval of the Government of India. To
attract investment in this sector, the
Government has gone in for a continuous
round the year bidding scheme for
exploration acreages, which provides regular
opportunities for companies to take up
blocks for exploration.
Private, including foreign companies, are
required to enter into production sharing
with the Government and can recover all
their costs before sharing profits with the
Government of India. An Empowered
Negotiating Committee comprising
representatives of the Ministry of
Petroleum, Finance, Law, ONGC, and Oil India
Ltd, has been set up to conduct negotiations
with various companies.
The Government has opened up the refining
sector to private investment. Private
companies are also encouraged to invest in
the marketing of petroleum products. In fact
a number of well known multinational
corporations namely Shell, Castrol, Mobil
etc. have already set up operations in the
country.
Roads. Private sector, including
foreign equity participation upto 100% in
the highways is envisaged under Build
Operate and Transfer (BOT) concept. Private
organisations who invest in identified
highway projects will be permitted to
recover their investment by way of
collection of tolls for specific periods.
The Government has identified 27 road
projects for investment by private parties,
involving US $ 4 bn. Letters of intent have
been issued for 5 highway projects involving
investment of US $ 119 m on BOT basis.
Ports and Shipping. The Government
grants automatic approval of foreign
investment of up to 51% in Indian shipping
companies. Private entrepreneurs are given
leases of berths and dry docks have been
privatised. Revised guidelines to facilitate
private sector investment in 11 major ports
have been approved by the Cabinet whereby
private sector participation has been
allowed in construction and operation of
additional assets, container terminals,
bulk, break bulk, multi purpose and
specialised cargo berths. Private parties
will also be invited for setting up captive
power plants at the ports.
Air taxi operations. The policy
envisages encouraging private sector
participation in air taxi operations.
Foreign equity participation up to 40% and
100% NRI equity are allowed, subject to the
approval of FIPB. The recently announced
Policy on Airport Infrastructure has allowed
private participation in the development of
airports.
Mining. Foreign equity up to 50% in
the mining sector would be automatic, except
for gold, silver, diamonds and precious
stones.
Private, including foreign investment in
coal mining is currently permitted for
captive consumption only (generation of
power, manufacture of steel etc. ) and for
setting up washeries. The new Coal and
Lignite (regulation and development ) Bill,
1997, envisages private participation in
coal mining.
INVESTMENT UNDER GLOBAL DEPOSITORY
RECEIPT MECHANISM
In 1992 a scheme was initiated to allow the
Indian Corporate Sector to have access to
the Global Capital Markets through the issue
of Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds (FCCBs)/
Equity Shares under the Global Depository
Mechanism. Under this scheme, companies with
a consistent track record of good
performance (financial or otherwise) for a
minimum period of three years can have
access to the international capital market.
Like their private sector counterparts,
various public sector entities like Videsh
Sanchar Nigam Ltd., Mahanagar Telephone
Nigam Ltd. and Steel Authority of India have
accessed the global capital markets and
issued GDRs to foreign investors.
Table 2: Inflow of Direct Foreign
Investment (FDI)
|
Actual FDI in respect of: |
Government’s
approval |
RBI’s Automatic
approval |
NRIs |
otal amount in rupees |
|
1991 |
1,911.8 |
- |
1,602.5 |
3,514.3 |
|
1992 |
4,779.5 |
4,75.4 |
1,496.9 |
6,751.8 |
|
1993 |
9,851.6 |
2,411 |
5,604.5 |
17,867.1 |
|
1994 |
15,007.6 |
3,625.8 |
11,185.1 |
29,818.5 |
|
1995 |
38,694.4 |
5,301.6 |
19,705.6 |
63,701.6 |
|
1996 |
57,589.1 |
6,196.2 |
20,620.4 |
84,405.7 |
|
1997 |
94,202.7 |
7,411 |
9,944 |
111,558.0 |
Total - Rs. 317,617.3 m / US $ 8,358.4 m
(1991 to November 1997)
Source : Reserve Bank of India (National
Information Centre).
Note: The dollar amounts, wherever
mentioned, have been converted @ Rs. 38 per
US $.
CONCLUSION
The Policy of Disinvestment has been viewed
as a positive step towards liberalisation as
is evident by the amelioration of PSUs being
opened up for privatisation. The Government
hopes to strengthen loss making PSUs so that
disinvestment of governmental equity in them
to the private sector becomes more
favourable and thereby increases the
country’s budgetary receipts.
The onset of liberalisation of the Indian
economy brought in its wake a marked
increase in total direct foreign investment
inflows into India. However, the country’s
political instability due to changing
governments was a deterrent to many foreign
investors.
With the formation of the new Government at
the centre, the feeling is once again of
buoyancy as it is envisaged that the
liberalisation policies are going to gather
force. Several sectors, such as the
Insurance sector, are expected to be opened
up for private participation. It is indeed a
positive sign that the country’s economic
policies are for long- term in nature and
encourage private participation.
|